tinykoi
All posts

Why searching titles is not enough: full-text search for bookmarks

· Guides · 4 min read

Full text search for bookmarks means you can find a saved page by any word that appears in it, not only by its title. That matters because titles are written for headlines, and you remember details. In tinykoi it is included on the free plan as well as Pro.

If your bookmark manager only searches titles, you are searching the least informative part of each page. Here is what changes when it searches the lot.

The problem with titles

A title is a few words chosen by someone else for a search engine or a front page. "10 things I learned" tells you nothing. "Untitled" is worse. Many pages are titled with the site name, and some saved links show only their domain.

What you actually remember is different: a phrase, a number, a name, an odd example. You remember that the article mentioned the "two-pizza rule" or a specific error code. None of that is in the title.

Some read-later tools make this a plan boundary. Instapaper's own docs say its Free plan searches titles only, and full-text search is a Premium feature. Raindrop's full-text search is on its Pro plan too, as is Karakeep's. Check any tool you are considering before you save a thousand links into it.

Full-text search for bookmarks in tinykoi

tinykoi has two layers, and both are on every plan.

Search across titles, tags and notes. Open the command palette and type. This is the quick lookup for things you named or labelled yourself. It matches addresses too.

Full-text search. It searches every word of every saved page, and the results show the lines that match. The feature list says it plainly: search every word of every page you saved. The free plan includes it, and so does Pro.

The free plan does not limit the number of bookmarks you save, so there is no point at which search quietly stops covering your library.

How matching behaves

Based on how tinykoi builds the search, a few details are worth knowing.

  • Words are matched as prefixes. Typing postg finds pages mentioning Postgres. You do not need to finish the word.
  • Several words narrow the results. A page has to match all the terms you type, so adding a word makes results more specific.
  • Only letters and digits count. Punctuation is ignored, so you search for words, not symbols.
  • At most ten terms are used from a query.
  • Matches are shown in context. When your words matched the saved page text, the result carries a short excerpt with up to two fragments, with your terms highlighted, so you can tell the right page from the wrong one without opening it.
  • Only the start of very long pages is scanned for the excerpt. The snippet looks at roughly the first 100,000 characters, so a match deep in a very long document may not get a highlighted line.

What gets searched

Full-text search runs on the text tinykoi captured when you saved the page. That is why the capture matters: the better the page text, the better the search. Pages are fetched in the background, so a bookmark you saved a moment ago may be searchable by title straight away and by its text a little later.

Titles and URLs also match on any part of the text you type, so a fragment of a web address works too.

Files are a separate case. PDFs, text and Markdown files open in the reader, but the feature list describes full-text search in terms of saved pages, so do not assume every word of every uploaded file is indexed.

Three searches that titles cannot do

  1. A quoted phrase you half remember. Type two or three distinctive words from the sentence. The matching lines show which page it was.
  2. Something from the middle of an article. The tool, the library or the person mentioned in paragraph nine.
  3. A bookmark you never titled. Saved from the right-click menu with no thought, but you remember something it said.

Each of these returns nothing in a titles-only tool, and you end up scrolling.

Why this matters more as the library grows

Ten bookmarks need no search. Ten thousand do, and the failure is gradual: you stop trusting the search, so you stop saving things, or you save the same page again. Searching the words inside each page keeps the library useful at any size. Saving a link you already have will not make a second copy, so you can also use the search to check before you save.

Pair it with meaning, if you want to

Full-text search is exact: it finds the words you typed. If you also want to find pages by idea, search by meaning adds matches on Pro, in the same list. The two do different jobs. Use exact words when you remember them and meaning when you do not.

What to do next

If your current tool searches titles only, try this test: pick a sentence from an article you saved last month and search for three words from it. If it comes back empty, you have your answer. Import your bookmarks into tinykoi, with folders becoming collections and tags coming along, then try the same search.

The pricing page lists what each plan adds. Full-text search is not on that list because it is already free. Create an account, no card needed.