tinykoi
All posts

How to find and clean up duplicate bookmarks

· Guides · 5 min read

Duplicate bookmarks come from saving the same page more than once, usually under slightly different links. tinykoi stops the obvious copies when you save, on every plan. On Pro, a duplicate finder groups the ones that slip through, and you choose which to keep.

Here is what counts as a duplicate, how each layer works, and a short routine for cleaning up a library that already has a few hundred of them.

Why duplicate bookmarks happen

You do not save duplicates on purpose. They arrive in a few ways:

  • You save a page, forget, and save it again months later.
  • You import an old bookmarks file on top of a library you already started.
  • The same article is reachable at several addresses: with and without www, with a tracking parameter on the end, through a short link, or on http and https.
  • A mobile version, an AMP version and a canonical version of a page are all in circulation.

The first two are easy to catch. The last two are harder, because the addresses do not match even though the page does.

Layer one: no duplicates on save

On every plan, saving a link you already have does not create a second copy. tinykoi compares a cleaned-up form of the address rather than the raw text, so these count as the same page:

  • A trailing slash, or none
  • A leading www. or none
  • A #fragment on the end
  • Tracking parameters such as utm_source, fbclid and gclid
  • Query parameters in a different order

That covers the usual copy and paste differences. The Chrome extension helps too. Its icon shows a check on pages you have already saved, so you can see at a glance that you do not need to save the tab again. Close your tabs uses this to triage a large pile.

This check is exact on the cleaned address. It does not know that a short link and the long link it points to are the same page, and it treats http and https as separate addresses. Those are what the finder is for.

Layer two: the duplicate finder on Pro

On Pro, tinykoi finds the same page saved under different links. It looks at where each link ends up, not only at the address you saved.

As part of its link checks, tinykoi follows each link to its destination and records the final address. If the page declares a canonical address that can be trusted, that is used instead. Bookmarks that resolve to the same place are grouped together, and the protocol is ignored, so http and https versions of one page land in the same group.

This catches:

  • Short links and the full address they redirect to
  • http and https versions of the same page
  • Mobile, AMP and other variants that point to one canonical page
  • Old and new addresses after a site moved a page with a permanent redirect

Until a bookmark has been checked, the finder falls back to comparing the saved address without its http or https. A new bookmark is picked up for its first check once it is about an hour old, and links are re-checked about once a month, so the finder gets better at spotting variants as your library gets checked. Link rot is the background to why tinykoi checks links at all.

Uploaded files and bookmarks in the trash are left out.

Clean up with the Duplicates page

On Pro, Duplicates appears in the library's navigation below the system views such as Unsorted and Trash.

Each group is a card listing every bookmark that shares a page. For each one you see its title, its address, its collection (or Unsorted) and the date you saved it. Within a group the oldest comes first, and the biggest groups are listed first, so the worst offenders are at the top.

Press Keep this one on the bookmark you want. The rest of the group goes to the trash. Nothing is deleted automatically and nothing is merged.

Two things to remember before you press it:

  • Notes and tags are not merged. If the copy you are trashing has a useful note or tag, copy it onto the one you keep first.
  • Trash is recoverable. Deleted bookmarks stay in the trash for 30 days, and the action shows a toast you can use to undo it.

The page loads fifty groups at a time. Use Show more to see the next batch.

A routine for a library with hundreds of duplicates

If you have just imported a big file, do the cleanup in this order.

  1. Let the checks run. Give a freshly imported library a few days. The finder is more accurate once links have been checked.
  2. Open Duplicates and work from the top. Large groups are usually a page you saved many times, so pick the copy that already sits in the right collection.
  3. Prefer the one with the note. If one copy has your note or tags, keep that one so you lose nothing.
  4. Empty the trash only when you are sure. Leave it for the 30 days if you are unsure.
  5. Come back in a month. Re-checks may surface new groups.

If your duplicates came from an import, exporting your Chrome bookmarks and importing the file once is cleaner than importing it repeatedly. Importing skips pages you already have, but variants of the same address are not caught until the finder sees them.

What to do on the free plan

The free plan has no duplicate finder, so exact copies are blocked and variants are yours to catch. Some habits help:

  • Search for the page before you save it. Search covers titles, tags and notes, and every word of every page you saved.
  • Trust the extension's check mark before you save a tab.
  • Sort by domain and look for runs of the same site when you tidy up.
  • Keep the library organised, so a repeat is easier to spot. Collections or tags can help you pick a structure.

If duplicates are your main problem and your library is large, that is a good reason to look at Pro. The pricing page lists exactly what it includes.

Keep it clean from here

Duplicates stop being a problem once saving is a habit and tidying is a monthly job. Sign up on the free plan, no card needed, and see the rest of what tinykoi does.